Super League Decision - A Fan's View
4 Jul 2008 | Kevin Finney
I’ve spent the last week talking to supporters from many clubs after my article last week. On Monday, here on www.lasttackle.com, we will be starting a new feature focussing on the fan’s views from some of the contenders in the race for a licence contest. Each day will feature the opinions of a different club. Monday is the turn of the Leigh Centurions supporters. Make sure you log on each day to get the views of the most important part of Rugby League: The fans.


My article last week seemed to cause a little bit of controversy with followers of some of the clubs getting in touch (thanks for the emails by the way). I seem to have touched a nerve, and for that I’m sorry, but I still stand by my opinions. I do, however, realise that the system I used – based on the Sky Sports way – will not be the same as the RFL. I felt it did give us a good guide. And I'm also very aware that I could be eating my words in a few weeks time.

Everyday my feelings on the matter change on who will get into Super League. In my opinion there are probably fifteen good bids vying for the fourteen places. Three points spring to mind that have helped me make my decision on the make up of the extended division

1) I cannot see, wrongly I know, the RFL removing an existing team. Maybe in three years, if clubs have not got their act together regarding stadia. But I believe the existing twelve to be safe.

2) With regards my inclusion of Widnes Vikings, I cannot see fourteen teams having a better bid than the Cheshire outfit. I can see Hull KR, Castleford, Wakefield, Salford, Celtic and Leigh all with a chance of missing out because all the of them cannot have a stronger bid than the Vikings.

3) The RFL seem set on expansion. If Celtic tick enough boxes to be included above another side then they will be in
.

On a personal level, I would like to see Widnes and Salford added into the Super League. In three years time, if the system is successful, we will have Celtic and Leigh knocking on the door. We could then make a sixteen team division, or even fifteen. Or replace a team that has failed to deliver.

Over the next few weeks you will read many conflicting views on who should make the final cut. Every supporter from each club I spoke to argues an extremely good case for their club’s conclusion. Sadly some will miss out. I just hope that these clubs manage to survive and have the opportunity to one day return to the top division.

kevin.finney@lasttackle.com
Share on Facebook | Del.icio.us | Discuss on our Forums
Your comment will only show after it has been approved.
League Tables
Pos Team Pld Pts
1 St Helens 25 40
2 Leeds 26 40
3 Catalans 25 34
4 Warrington 25 28
5 Wigan 26 28
6 Bradford 25 24
7 Hull KR 25 21
8 Wakefield 25 20
9 Harlequins 26 20
10 Huddersfield 25 19
11 Hull FC 26 17
12 Castleford 25 13
Pos Team Pld Pts
1 Salford 17 44
2 Celtic 17 37
3 Halifax 17 35
4 Leigh 17 31
5 Widnes 17 29
6 Whitehaven 17 29
7 Featherstone 17 26
8 Sheffield 17 26
9 Batley 17 23
10 Dewsbury 17 12
Pos Team Pld Pts
1 Gateshead 22 59
2 Barrow 20 49
3 Oldham 21 49
4 Doncaster 20 42
5 Keighley 20 42
6 York 21 39
7 Rochdale 21 36
8 Workington 21 28
9 Swinton 21 22
10 Blackpool 21 22
11 London 20 18
12 Hunslet 20 16
Pos Team Pld Pts
1 Manly 19 28
2 Melbourne 19 26
3 Sydney 18 24
4 Cronulla 18 24
5 Brisbane 18 21
6 St George 18 20
7 Penrith 19 19
8 Canberra 18 18
9 Gold Coast 19 18
10 NZ Warriors 18 18
11 Newcastle 18 16
12 Wests 18 16
13 Parramatta 18 16
14 Souths 18 12
15 Canterbury 18 10
16 North QLD 18 6
Latest Results
Hull FC 26-6 Harlequins
22/08/08 | Att: 12,269 | Report

Wigan 16-52 Leeds
22/08/08 | Att: 14,778 | Report

Huddersfield 20-22 Catalans
17/08/08 | Att: 12,127 | Report

Bradford 42-14 Hull FC
17/08/08 | Att: 9,181 |

Harlequins 16-32 St Helens
17/08/08 | Att: 3,629 |

Warrington 34-36 Hull KR
17/08/08 | Att: 8,530 |

Sheffield 34-28 Dewsbury
22/08/08 | Att: 815

Salford 46-0 Batley
17/08/08 | Att: 2,761

Leigh 32-8 Whitehaven
17/08/08 | Att: 3,522

Halifax 28-38 Celtic
17/08/08 | Att: 2,482

Dewsbury 18-36 Featherstone
17/08/08 | Att: 1,074

Sheffield 20-26 Widnes
14/08/08 | Att: 1,823

Gateshead 22-18 Doncaster
21/08/08 | Att: 1,751

Workington 14-22 Gateshead
17/08/08 | Att: 603

Swinton 20-38 Oldham
17/08/08 | Att: 685

Rochdale 42-12 London
17/08/08 | Att: 459

Blackpool 42-26 Hunslet
17/08/08 | Att: 424

Barrow 22-8 Keighley
15/08/08 | Att: 1,747

Wests Melbourne
14/07/08 | Att:

Brisbane Caterbury
13/07/08 | Att:

St George Canberra
13/07/08 | Att:

South Sydney Parramatta
12/07/08 | Att:

Cronulla Manly
12/07/08 | Att:

NZ Warriors North QLD
12/07/08 | Att:

Upcoming Fixtures
Catalans v Wakefield
23/08/08 | KO: 20:00

Huddersfield v St Helens
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Bradford v Hull KR
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Castleford v Warrington
24/08/08 | KO: 15:30

St Helens v Wigan
05/09/08 | KO: 19:30

Harlequins v Catalans
07/09/08 | KO: 15:00

Celtic v Salford
23/08/08 | KO: 17:30

Batley v Leigh
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Featherstone v Halifax
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Whitehaven v Widnes
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

London v Blackpool
23/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Keighley v Hunslet
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Oldham v Workington
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Swinton v Barrow
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

York v Rochdale
24/08/08 | KO: 15:00

Doncaster v Hunslet
29/08/08 | KO: 20:00

Site4Sport
Chat Forum
How do we become top of league once again
by mark_p
August 29, 2008, 09:55:57 PM
starting team we have let leave the club
by mark_p
August 29, 2008, 09:54:25 PM
Toulouse Long Trek
by ThunderClap - NewMan
August 29, 2008, 09:45:06 PM
end of season do!
by robgardner
August 29, 2008, 07:41:32 PM
attendance stats, league games only
by greyhound
August 29, 2008, 07:41:09 PM